Claudia's Three of a Kind Comments THREE OF A KIND
AIR DATE:  May 2, 1999
Written by Vince Gilligan and John Shiban
Directed by Bryan Spicer

"Three of a Kind" was an entertaining non Scully and Mulder episode with the Lone Gunmen being able to keep us interested which isn't always easy since the main reason we watch X-Files is for Scully and Mulder, not the supporting characters. It is surprising how well writers Vince Gilligan and John Shiban were able to pull this off considering this has been a weak year for Gilligan scripts. The biggest surprise in "Three of a Kind", which is why I liked it so much, is the Lone Gunmen with Scully's help actually are able to pull one over the bad guys. There wasn't the usual they have the information in their hands only to lose it by the end of the episode. I have been waiting for a little victory since season 4 as it has become a cliche for Scully and Mulder to have nothing by the end of an episode making them unable to expose the truth. It was a refreshing ending when we see Susanne Modeski driving off and Timmy in jail for the murder of Jimmy. The Lone Gunmen go to Las Vegas to investigate a military industrial complex convention to see if they can get any lowdown on what they are up to and Byers has a secret agenda to find Susanne Modeski. This was another good thing about the episode in that it actually remembers the past correctly and we get to find out what happened to Susanne Modeski and that Byers is still pining for her. The opening teaser was a great X-Files moment where Byers tells us his dream of having a normal life with a wife and kids and the country still trusts its elected leaders. A dream he's had to have over the years considering how frustrating it has to be trying to expose government corruption without any luck. What is really amazing about the opening teaser is that the voiceover works. How many voiceovers have we had this season that make you groan. Also, it was fun to meet some of their fellow conspiracy buffs who also go around to these conventions trying to get the dope on the latest government conspiracy though it is hard to believe these different military companies would be so forthcoming with each other about their latest weapon development. Oh heck, there has been so much consolidation in the industry it is hard to believe they aren't all owned by the same company. A few comments on "Three of a Kind": - Did anyone else think actor Bruce Harwood during the opening teaser was glad that the golden retriever didn't bite his hand off as he handed him a treat so the dog would go up to him? - Ever since the X-files moved to L.A. anytime they use any type of California scenery I can't help thinking they are getting their money's worth out of this move. - It is always good to see Charles Rocket get some work since no one can play a sleezeball weasel as well as he can. Though I do feel sorry for him because FOX didn't even bother to put his name in their press release. Well, at least not on their internet schedule site. - I must be out of it because I have never heard of the saying "What stones he has" as one of the those Defense Contractors guys said. Now I have heard the saying "What balls he has." Hmm, I wonder why FOX would have them say "stones" instead of "balls." - It was nice to know the Lone Gunmen have friends, but did they have to go the stereotype route that all these guys are geeks. - We get one of those Closed Caption moments when Byers and Frohike are walking through the Casino and we hear them talking about the poker game Byers lost, but the Closed Caption has them talking about Starsky and Hutch. Now I wonder why they had them talking about Starsky and Hutch in the script. - The Lone Gunmen were taking a big chance that Scully wouldn't call Mulder back on her home phone instead of her cellular phone. Of course, the thought of Scully using her home phone instead of her cellular phone would be completely unnatural for her. - For a big hotel they only have one maid working a floor? I've been to smaller ones where they have a whole crew working a floor. - I'm a little surprised Byers didn't go with Jimmy to see what was going on at the conference. Of course, if he did, then Jimmy couldn't have been caught by the bad guys and made to kill himself. One of those plot conveniences that needs to happen if the story is going to work. I don't know why they felt the need to kill off Jimmy since it didn't really stop the Lone Gunmen. Also, we get the classic we'll kill off someone we barely know, but we won't have them kill off one of the main characters (Scully and Langly). - Thank God the hotel conveniently had those ventilation units that are big enough for humans to fit through. Where would movies and tv shows be without them. - The only part of the episode I didn't like was the mind controlling drug. I don't know why I've always had a hard time believing that stuff. Especially when it affects one of the main characters and even more so when it was used more for jokes than anything else. It was a nice touch to have Michael McKean come back as Morris Fletcher and have Scully slap him on the butt. - Timmy was using that mind controlling drug a little bit too liberally so it was only right that he would get his just desserts and they have the Lone Gunmen use it against him. - Lucky for Scully and Langly, Susanne Modeski and her boyfriend thought of developing a counteracting agent to the drug and they happened to bring some with them on the trip. - It is hard to believe Timmy's government friends wouldn't try to get him out of jail for the murder of Jimmy. I guess Timmy knows who his real friends are. An unexpectedly enjoyable episode considering the X-Files track record on episodes that barely feature Scully and Mulder. Also, one of the finer scripts from Vince Gilligan and John Shiban. We got to see what the Lone Gunmen do in their spare time and realize some of them wish for a normal life, but know they can never have it because of what they know. And for once the writers let them win one against the conspiracy which is something we don't see enough on the show. It was a nice look into the lives of the Lone Gunmen who we usually only see for about 3 minutes in episodes. Claudia E-Mail: Claudia.Cauchon@unh.edu 6/7/99

Back to Top of Page

Back to 6th Season Episodes List 1st Season Episodes List 2nd Season Episodes List
3rd Season Episodes List 4th Season Episodes List 5th Season Episodes List
Back to Main X-Files Comment Page